Informe • Board Game Arena

Tots els informes

Japanese (Riichi) Mahjong informes

#46537: "Cannot know whether discarded tile is just drawn tile or a tile from hand"

implemented: El suggeriment ha estat implementat

De què tracta aquest informe?

Japanese (Riichi) Mahjong #193940433

Què ha passat? Si us plau, selecciona a sota

Suggeriment: al meu entendre, aquesta idea pot millorar molt la implementació del joc

Què ha passat? Si us plau, selecciona a sota

Suggeriment: al meu entendre, aquesta idea pot millorar molt la implementació del joc

Si us plau, comprova si ja existeix un informe sobre el mateix tema

En cas afirmatiu, si us plau VOTA per aquest informe. Els informes amb més vots tenen PRIORITAT!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Descripció detallada

Historial de denúncies

13 Aug 2021 23:04 • ufm • L'error encara no ha estat reproduït pels desenvolupadors:

16 Aug 2021 19:02 • GTSchemer • L'error encara no ha estat reproduït pels desenvolupadors:

As a point of comparison, FFXIV implements dark grey to indicate a drawn tile was immediately discarded: i.ytimg.com/vi/qEOJ6rP08gA/maxresdefault.jpg

Normal white tiles indicate a discard from the hand that was NOT the newly drawn tile.

Also, FFXIV uses a red coloring to indicate a discarded tile was called by another player.

17 Aug 2021 00:40 • gilthe • Els desenvolupadors encara no han analitzat aquest suggeriment:

Thanks for the info! In physical play, you can see of course which actual tile was discarded irrespective of discard or not. At the same time, nothing enforces hand-sorting in physical play, but it would be really inconvenient to not have it online. I think Tenhou shows discard identity but does not enforce shuffling, does anybody know for suret?
I don't have a complete overview, but it seems to me that clients are not homogeneous in this regard. Iirc the Yakuza 0 implementation obscures it completely. For me it was fine to obscure completely, but a second option could be added as suggested (distinguish discard of draw from all other cases), either graphically or by notification.I don't think this is a bug, though.

17 Aug 2021 00:40 • gilthe • Els desenvolupadors estan d'acord que és una bona idea i estan planejant treballar-hi:

I reclassified this from bug to suggestion.

17 Aug 2021 00:40 • gilthe • Els desenvolupadors estan d'acord que és una bona idea i estan planejant treballar-hi:

I reclassified this from bug to suggestion.

17 Aug 2021 00:47 • GTSchemer • Els desenvolupadors estan d'acord que és una bona idea i estan planejant treballar-hi:

I agree it is a suggestion. I do not know about Tenhou, but in general I think having a grey coloring to indicate drawn tiles being discarded would be fair and not cause problems.

It is useful because if you see several grey discards in a row, you suspect someone is mostly happy with their hand, and is looking for something in particular.

17 Aug 2021 03:44 • ufm • Els desenvolupadors estan d'acord que és una bona idea i estan planejant treballar-hi:

Yakuza 0 (the one developer mentioned), tenhou, and majsoul does not shade tiles discarded just after being drawn, however they indicate it by animation.
When a player draws a tile, the tile is placed on the rightmost side. If the tile is discarded it does not shuffled in. If kept, it gets shuffled in hand and another tile is discarded from hand.
Tenhou and majsoul display the information only during the replay though. I think that's why the developer thought it shows the identity during the game (found the screenshot or video but didn't know it being a replay).
FFXIV (the one GTSchemer brought) and SEGA MJ applies shading during the game.

To sum up, it is quite inconsistent but all clients/implementations notify the information in a manner.

17 Aug 2021 17:23 • gilthe • Els desenvolupadors estan d'acord que és una bona idea i estan planejant treballar-hi:

Thanks @ufm, that's helpful.

I had indeed seen both live play and replay on tenhou in video before but confused the two last night (was late ;-)

17 Aug 2021 17:27 • GTSchemer • Els desenvolupadors estan d'acord que és una bona idea i estan planejant treballar-hi:

Nice summary ufm! Of those options, the shading is the most async-friendly, but I'm not against animation as well if it's not overdone. I would just be afraid I'd miss it when I load up an async game.

31 Aug 2021 02:08 • nccc • Els desenvolupadors estan d'acord que és una bona idea i estan planejant treballar-hi:

And could u HIGHLIGHT the card just discarded as well, ty!

25 Sep 2021 01:12 • gilthe • El suggeriment ha estat implementat:

I implemented both source-of-tile highlighting (fresh draw or already in hand) and highlighting of the current active discard. Note that if automatic pass options are set, you might not see the current active discard highlighting because the tile is no longer claimable. The source of the tile is also reported in the notifications.

25 Sep 2021 04:10 • ufm • El suggeriment ha estat implementat:

The log works well, but source-of-tile highlighting is somehow not applied even without autopass.

Afegeix quelcom a aquest report

Si us plau afegiu aquí qualsevol cosa que sembli rellevant per tal de reproduir aquest error o entendre el vostre suggeriment:

Un altre ID de partida / ID de moviment
Prémer F5 ha ajudat a arreglar el problema?
El problema apareix diversos cops? Cada cop? a l'atzar?
If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here.

Cancel·lar Actualitzar informe

#46537: "Cannot know whether discarded tile is just drawn tile or a tile from hand"

De què tracta aquest informe?

Què ha passat? Si us plau, selecciona a sota

Què ha passat? Si us plau, selecciona a sota

Si us plau, comprova si ja existeix un informe sobre el mateix tema

Descripció detallada

Historial de denúncies

Afegeix quelcom a aquest report

Canvia l'estat de l'informe a:

Ajuda

Contribuir

Navega

Segueix-nos