Informe • Board Game Arena

Tots els informes

Automobiles informes

#45612: "Momentum didn't apply until someone moves"

fixed: L'error ha estat arreglat

De què tracta aquest informe?

Automobiles #190077508

Què ha passat? Si us plau, selecciona a sota

Regles: una regla del joc no ha estat respectada

Què ha passat? Si us plau, selecciona a sota

Regles: una regla del joc no ha estat respectada

Si us plau, comprova si ja existeix un informe sobre el mateix tema

En cas afirmatiu, si us plau VOTA per aquest informe. Els informes amb més vots tenen PRIORITAT!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Descripció detallada

Historial de denúncies

27 Jul 2021 13:48 • godzengqi • L'error encara no ha estat reproduït pels desenvolupadors:

Table #190077508
Move #70
According to the rule, all cars should move forward automatically until reach another car or at the top of one space. At the beginning of this game, we spent some turns shopping without moving and the leader car, which belongs to the red player, didn't move to cross the start line automatically. However, another player moved trigger the momentum and move the red car. This happened in move#70.

27 Jul 2021 13:56 • BaronFraser • L'error encara no ha estat reproduït pels desenvolupadors:

Hey there,

I'm not sure if BGA will let me properly replay your game until you've finished it (at least, I've never figure out how), but can I confirm: is this purely about the VERY FIRST move in Tucson? (ie did a player sit on the start line and not move until turn 70?)

If so, I will triple check with game designer, but that behaviour is based on the rules which are specified for that map:

"The checkered flag that marks the start/finish line cuts through two spaces (A and B). These spaces should still be treated as normal spaces with the checkered flag serving like any other dashed segment line.However, the player starting the game on “P1: $10” should treat that segment as a distinct space until they move out of it. This means, for example, if they play one white cube on their first turn they would move forward 1 segment to the front of space A. Likewise, player 1 should ignore momentum until they have moved out of space A."

So, momentum does not apply to that first space on Tucson until you have moved.

Does that sound like it matches the issue that you had?

27 Jul 2021 14:11 • godzengqi • L'error encara no ha estat reproduït pels desenvolupadors:

Do you mean the first player should never momentum across the start line if it doesn't move is follow the rule? In our game, the first player momentum across the line(move#70) in the other player's end phase but he doesn't move in this turn and the turns before. The rule seems to be broken when the other player moves before the first player chooses to move. How can we let you check the game? If we all abandon the game, it will let you check?

27 Jul 2021 14:15 • BaronFraser • L'error encara no ha estat reproduït pels desenvolupadors:

Hail! Thanks for the reply.

Keep playing your game. But let me know when it's done and I'll be able to study the replay then.

If I understand correctly, the bug may be in the OTHER direction... if the first player moved over the line with momentum after ANOTHER player overtook them, then I don't think that is meant to happen. There's simply meant to be no momentum in that first space until you have moved - but I have sent David Short a request for an absolute clarification.

Thanks for reporting it! Please let me know when your game is over.

27 Jul 2021 14:19 • godzengqi • L'error encara no ha estat reproduït pels desenvolupadors:

I will update in here if we finished.
Thank you for your support.

27 Jul 2021 16:46 • godzengqi • L'error encara no ha estat reproduït pels desenvolupadors:

Hi! Thank you for waiting so long.
We've finished the game and please check it.

28 Jul 2021 01:52 • BaronFraser • S'ha confirmat l'error per part dels desenvolupadors:

Hi godzengqi,

I've heard back from David Short *and* reviewed the replay - thanks for that.

I can confirm that the P1 segment in Tucson is a special case and there is no momentum out of that space UNTIL A PLAYER HAS MOVED. That's not a global rule about momentum - it's just a special rule for that track.

Which means that I *can* confirm a bug from your replay, but it's not the one you were expecting! When IzWzl moved into the black space, Flareworks should NOT have momentumed forwards like they did: it seems that my implementation incorrectly has momentum kicking in for that space once *anyone* has moved rather than once the player has moved.

Otherwise, the holding up of players on the straights on Tucson is... a strategy. It didn't ultimately work for Flareworks here (congratulations on your win!)

Thanks for the report!

18 May 2022 10:05 • BaronFraser • L'error ha estat arreglat:

Hey there,

Apologies for the incredibly lengthy delay but I can confirm that the actual bug here (if you are the starting car in Tucson, Momentum should NOT apply to you until you have moved) has been fixed.

Afegeix quelcom a aquest report

Si us plau afegiu aquí qualsevol cosa que sembli rellevant per tal de reproduir aquest error o entendre el vostre suggeriment:

Un altre ID de partida / ID de moviment
Prémer F5 ha ajudat a arreglar el problema?
El problema apareix diversos cops? Cada cop? a l'atzar?
Si tens una captura de pantalla d'aquest error (bona pràctica), pots utilitzar Imgur.com per pujar-ho i copiar i enganxar el link aquí.

Cancel·lar Actualitzar informe

#45612: "Momentum didn't apply until someone moves"

De què tracta aquest informe?

Què ha passat? Si us plau, selecciona a sota

Què ha passat? Si us plau, selecciona a sota

Si us plau, comprova si ja existeix un informe sobre el mateix tema

Descripció detallada

Historial de denúncies

Afegeix quelcom a aquest report

Canvia l'estat de l'informe a:

Ajuda

Contribuir

Navega

Segueix-nos